's Court of Shanghai Institute of Foreign Trade Teacher Feng Juan (a pseudonym) v. Meyers (a pseudonym) reputation infringement case first instance verdict, dismissed the plaintiff's claim,mulberry. The Court ruled that Hooch in the network log on with the debate between the users, although inappropriate, but only my personal view, not social evaluation of the plaintiff's impact. May 10, the defendant agent, Shanghai Wenhui Lawyer Min Rong Fu told reporters that the case is Shanghai's first university teachers v students reputation infringement case, the judgment of this case will be in the future such disputes serve as a model effect. The competition between the two taekwondo bodies in September 2007, as the Shanghai Institute of Foreign Trade Taekwondo club president, Hu Qi satisfied that the new activities encountered an unexpected situation: the same time there is even another taekwondo organizations are also satisfied that the new. Making inquiries, Hu Wizards figure it out: In the original, the new school set up a Taekwondo team (school teams) and interest groups, discretionary management FENG Juan teachers by the Ministry of Sports, to employ of Shanghai Ning Yubo force Taekwondo coach as coach . Meyers said: "some elective Feng teacher physical education students, said Von teacher in the classroom for the interest classes publicity, we recommend to attend, points and promised sports scores Riga,hollister." "This is so unfair! Hooch and taekwondo club Rotarians, the emergence of this interest classes undoubtedly influenced the development of taekwondo club. "More than ever,hollister, the new recruit the number of dropped three percent." After some investigation, Hooch interest classes in the management of "chaos". Rotarians and I found that the registration and training of students did not receive any invoices,mulberry, receipts or class certificates in March last year, Hu Qi and Rotarians visited one after another school-related departments "seek explanation. They help to the leadership of the Communist Youth League school, the defendant's right to interfere; They have also told a deputy principals submitted a joint letter, but let the matter rest. Internet access for students to write the log after the alleged infringement to find a school to say unsuccessful, in late May 2008, Meyers published in their own school network on the home page called "our school two taekwondo bodies ......" log that, in foreign trade College Taekwondo club and Feng interest classes and school team responsible for the difference. Log is issued, interest classes and members of the school team Message reviews, criticized Meyers rumor mongering, Hu Qi Feng enrollment in the discussion questioned the economic accounts. "You may think that Feng is not wrong, but I understand that you know the students money to go ..." "... that von teacher take kickbacks how much you want me to say out " "I do Societies the idea is that we play together 'training courses' side ...... maybe people's goal is to dominate the country, perhaps to make trouble tertiary industry, perhaps ... "Hooch these remarks in the post soon caused by Feng Juan's attention, and soon he will be subject to pressure from the school. "A month later, the counselor came to me, I hope I withdraw posts to Feng public apology,mulberry outlet." Meyers said, "Later, I immediately delete the log, but I'm not wrong, a public apology impossible." Stubborn Hu odd insists that he is right, and he did not know,louboutin, a lawsuit waiting for him. In September 2008, Feng Juan to Shanghai's Songjiang District People's Court proceedings, sued the same school Law School Grade 3 students Hooch against his honor. Min Rong Fu lawyer told reporters after the receipt of the respondent notice, he had contact with Feng Juan, I want her to give up litigation, do not magnify the campus disputes, but declined. After Min Rong Fu twice sent letters to the president and party secretary of the Shanghai Institute of Foreign Trade, pointed out that the school is, after all, is studying students, I hope to come forward to mobilize school teacher withdrawal, to avoid the deterioration of the situation. However, these efforts have not been the echo of the school. The court dismissed the plaintiff's claim March 3rd, 2009, the the Songjiang district court on this case and trial. The plaintiff pointed out that the defendant accused the plaintiff in its log "engage in marketing", "take kickbacks", "engaged in the tertiary industry, no basis in fact, a violation of the right of reputation, resulting in a plaintiff reduction of social evaluation. In this regard, Min Rong Fu lawyer said that the the plaintiff posting just a question of "not counting" approach, the content is true, no defamation framed, and thus does not constitute an infringement of the right of reputation. The issue of the invoice, the plaintiff explained, "is not no invoice,mulberry outlet, but in the hands of the Minister of the Department of Physical Education, the leaders did not give me, I have no idea." Hooch, the school site is the personal blog website with privacy protection system,hollister outlet, and only friends can see. Of Physical Education Department put pressure on and counselors to persuade, and soon withdraw posts, it is not possible to result in lower Feng social evaluation. Min Rong Fu Counsel further pointed out that the school itself is a violation of China's education department under the Office Taekwondo interest classes. The plaintiff argued, interest classes are allowed to set up and manage school fees run classes is not an individual act,mulberry outlet, whether the violation she did not know. In the judgment, the Court pointed out that the the the network log evidence submitted by the plaintiff is not notarized and therefore not certified for its authenticity. Even if the network log is true, it is only the defendant in the course of the debate with friends in some personal views. Plaintiff outstanding achievements in Taekwondo team, responsible for the school and Taekwondo interest groups during the school merit award,air jordan, the social evaluation obtained by the plaintiff is not actually reduced. Therefore, the plaintiff's claim is not supported. The best way of looking for defenders Commentary Zhang Liang honorary title dispute in modern society is another common, but every day there are about tens of thousands of pieces into the proceedings. The case was aroused widespread concern in society, in that it occurs in a special subject. University of existence value one is reserved for the social conscience and thought. Based on this, the University and its teachers should have an open heart, can accommodate criticism and dissent. Should educate students about the rights of teachers: it is not a gift, is the need to actively seek, if necessary, may be life for the price. But when his own attack by the students, he must be able to be tolerant to diversity. Because he is a man ', he wants to shape in the minds of the students what is tall for any standard for the lowly, he wants the student demonstration, a true citizen is how are we to take seriously their rights and at forgive others for their misunderstanding the. The true meaning of the rule of law, not to train citizens aggressive gene, but to achieve the harmony of human relationships. Each of us has the right to safeguard their rights, but also should assume find the obligation to maintain the right to the best way. All contradictions to the court,hogan outlet, trying to solve all litigation is unrealistic. Increasing emphasis on "harmony", the reality is more of a wide range of solutions to choose from disputes. The present case, Feng teacher's right of action should be firmly maintained. Contradiction of the teacher-student relationship, should not lead to the right to litigate been apparent,oakley, this is a society governed by the rule of law should have the feelings. (Trainee newspaper reporter Zhang Liang)

Related articles:

• there is an urgent need to re-built. In January 2009
• the company had a compensation
• 00 more than the next day

上一篇： the parents of the child to school on to explain 下一篇： a total of 81 people. Identify each victim Lee's wife